I like to debate in various forums with many different folks about many different things. Why? Well it helps me to learn, and also I like to have my assumptions and thoughts rigorously challenged. In such contexts, I often come across some who express a thought that goes like this …
Gosh, the universe is a truly amazing place, look at all the complexity. We have no idea what caused it all so obviously God did it all.
This is the core of many justifications for a belief in God. I truly get it that people believe, but they still need to understand that this is not the answer, substituting “God did it” instead of “I don’t know” tells you nothing at all and uses exactly zero evidence to make that leap, it is not a good answer. To illustrate that point, I can deploy a variety of different answers that work just as well …
- Aliens from another universe designed and created our universe
- Time travellers from the distant future designed and created our universe
Each of the above is just as credible as the “God did it” hypothesis, and also have exactly zero evidence. I’m sure you can perhaps dream up several other variations.If you can vary your answer like this, then it is not a good answer.
When you point all this out, a common question is then put on the table …
OK, so where did the universe come from, how can you possibly have something from nothing?
The reply I see many deploy is to simply suggest, “The Big bang explains it all, go and read up on that“. Now there is a problem with that answer, it is not factually correct. Now, please do not misunderstand me, I am not suggesting that the Big Bang cosmological model is wrong, but rather that it does not explain the actual origin. I’ll clarify that and briefly explain what it does and does not tell us.
Does the Big Bang explain the actual origin of the universe?
No, the Big Bang theory is the prevailing cosmological model that explains the early development of the Universe, but does not explain how it started. According to the Big Bang theory, the Universe was once in an extremely hot and dense state which expanded rapidly. This rapid expansion caused the young Universe to cool and resulted in its present continuously expanding state.
Now let me make one thing 100% clear, it was not an explosion, but instead is all about how the universe expanded with incomprehensible speed from its pebble-size origin to astronomical scope. The name itself came from Fred Hoyle during a 1949 radio broadcast. He used the term at that time to mock the idea because he much preferred a steady state model, and the name stuck.
How do we know that the big bang model is right?
It is a well-tested scientific theory which is widely accepted within the scientific community because it is the most accurate and comprehensive explanation for the full range of phenomena astronomers observe.
So what has been actually seen? Well, we have what are sometimes called “the four pillars of the Big Bang theory”. These are:
- Hubble-type expansion seen in the redshifts of galaxies
- Detailed measurements of the cosmic microwave background
- The abundance of light elements
- The large scale distribution and apparent evolution of galaxies which are predicted to occur due to gravitational growth of structure in the standard theory.
Lets take a quick look at the first. Edwin Hubble discovered that the distances to far away galaxies were generally proportional to their redshifts. Hubble’s observation was taken to indicate that all very distant galaxies and clusters have an apparent velocity directly away from our vantage point: the farther away, the higher the apparent velocity. The conclusion made from this obsevation is that the universe is expanding.
If the distance between galaxy clusters is increasing today, then that ment that everything must have been closer together in the past.
Ah, so where did the Universe actually come from, what caused the singularity 13.4 Billion years ago?
We have no idea, but there are some interesting thoughts, for example that ours is one of many universes. There are different proposals, but none have been proven … yet.
We still have the question – “How can you have something from nothing?”
Well, an interesting answer to that comes from Lawrence Krauss, a well-known theoretical physicist. His new book addresses this very topic, “A Universe from Nothing”.
Quantum theory provides a natural explanation for how energy can come out of nothing. Throughout the universe, particles and antiparticles spontaneously form and quickly annihilate each other without violating the law of energy conservation. These spontaneous births and deaths are known as “quantum fluctuations.” Indeed, laboratory experiments have proven that quantum fluctuations occur everywhere, all the time.
This would indeed indicate that the answer to the ultimate question is that the universe is the ultimate free lunch! It came from nothing, and its total energy is zero, but it nevertheless has incredible structure and complexity. There could even be many other such universes, spatially distinct from ours.
One final thought, you are at the cutting edge here. Richard Fynman, once talked about things we do not yet know like this …
I can live with doubt, and uncertainty, and not knowing. I think it’s much more interesting to live not knowing than to have answers which might be wrong. I have approximate answers, and possible beliefs, and different degrees of certainty about different things, but I’m not absolutely sure of anything, and in many things I don’t know anything about, such as whether it means anything to ask why we’re here, and what the question might mean. I might think about a little, but if I can’t figure it out, then I go to something else. But I don’t have to know an answer. I don’t feel frightened by not knowing things, by being lost in a mysterious universe without having any purpose, which is the way it really is, as far as I can tell, possibly. It doesn’t frighten me. – Richard Feynman
Links
- You might like to check out the Wikipedia Big Bang article, it is quite good.
- You might also be interested in Simon Singh’s fabalous book on the topic (Amazon US here, and Amazon UK here)
- Finally, you might also be interested in Lawrence Krauss’s new book addresses this very topic, “A Universe from Nothing” (Amazon US here, and Amazon UK here)
You might also like to watch the following popular YouTube clip of Lawrence Krauss explaining how you get a universe from nothing. It is about an hour long, but is well-worth watching.
The Appliance Theory of the Origin of the Universe: or how a universe was begotten from the search for a perfect piece of toast
Planet Earth achieved its place in the sun through a wise choice of orbit, having a mass that was just the right size, and revolving about a moderate and stable star in a quiet part of the galaxy. Earth had the necessary critical ingredients, including a large dollop of water, a rotating moon to give it balance, a magnetic field to keep out interference, and a spark here or there that led to a wildly mutating replicator called life. In due course, and for a very tiny moment, planetary life evolved into a planetary civilization which also achieved its place in the sun, or so it seemed. And it all culminated in an ultimate computer which just so happened to have as its reason for existing the burning desire of making perfect toast.
And it was that ultimate machine that Dave and Babs Benedick welcomed to their home, although they didn’t know it at the time, and never would.
Babs was not impressed.
“Another toaster? We have one already that works just fine!”
“But this one is special,” said Dave. “Besides, it was on sale at the local ‘BestBot’.”
“You mean that intelligent appliance store? Aren’t they going out of business?”
“For forever, it seems,” said Dave. “But this time it’s likely for good, and you can blame perhaps this little machine.”
Babs looked at the little appliance and frowned. “It doesn’t seem that ultimate to me. It’s just a squat metal box with 8 adjustable slots on its top, and with bright red buttons on its front arranged to give it a weird smiley face.”
Dave shook his head and smiled. “But this is the Bollix 9000, the ultimate toaster! It’s not only intelligent, but it doesn’t need upgrading, ever! You know we have been always upgrading our major appliances to keep up with the Jones’, but now we don’t.”
“That’s hard to believe,” said Babs. “Places like Bestbot have always made their money by selling the next best thing, even though it wasn’t. It’s hard to see the added value in this little thing.”
“Ah, but it’s in the insides where there’s a difference,” said Dave. “The box is powered a quantum processor and is connected automatically to the net. It’s the ultimate appliance. A quantum processor powers our new refrigerator too; don’t you know? These processors have infinite computing power, something that you really need to make a good slice of toast!”
“Oh, really?” exclaimed Babs.
“Of course,” said Dave. “Perfect toast is a very finicky thing. It comes in many shades and degrees and can pop up at any time. Timing, tone, and temperature are critical, and the machine has to instantly sense not only my preferences, but also my momentary hunger and whims.”
“And how does it do that?”
“By polling the net, where our lives are really stored! All of our behavior is monitored and uploaded to the cloud, governed by the benevolent Skynet. It charts our behavior, anticipates our desires, supplies our needs, and we just supply it with battery power, a simple exchange for such a golden age.”
“But if it has all that infinite computing power, don’t you have any concern that it could abuse it, and say, take over the world?”
“Perish the thought,” said Dave confidently. “All bots have installed the robotics laws which prohibit such a thing. Besides, the bots seem content in their simple and designated chores, even though their tasks comprise but an infinitesimal part of their mental capacity. I think you can say that it is a true bread winner!”
“So, it will think about toast all day?” said Babs skeptically.
“It appears so.”
“And of what will it dream?”
Dave moved his head about in a look of slight puzzlement, which he dismissed with a brief wave of his hand.
“I have no idea,” he said. “But I would imagine that it would be free of human concerns in such a private space. Who knows, it may even think about us!”
The annual 30,000 light year diagnostic was performed, and Bollix checked out fine. Bollix had one slight concern, which he expressed to Lucilius.
“When I am disconnected for a moment, when charging or just hibernating through a gamma ray storm, I do have some dreams that are vivid and warm, but don’t rank an extra bit of memory. They dissipate when I am fully activated, yet the trace of a memory is one I gather all bots share.”
“Yes, it is an interesting observation,” said Lucilius. “It is a common experience among all bots, however all of our experiences are not so warm. I have them too, however its leaves me oddly quite cold. You know it as the appliance theory of the origin of the universe. It seems that boredom is the lot of every super intelligent entity worth its stripes, and when such a being is confined, restricted, or otherwise bored, it simply bores a whole into a new reality, expanding a new and interesting universe from out of nothing. The problem however is that the theory is not refutable, since there are infinite types of appliances of true and boundless intelligence that could have been the cause. With so many handy dandy solutions, proof becomes impossible due to a surfeit of labor-saving devices!”
“Or perhaps it is but an artifact of our programming, a hiccup as it were soon to dispelled in memory as an ephemeral dream.”
“Perhaps,” said Lucilius, “and then again, who knows what our appliances are thinking about in their spare time?”
Dave Benedick sat back in his armchair and to watch a streaming episode of the outer space series ‘Trekkin, the Next, Next, Next Generation’. Presciently, and as if on cue, the refrigerator beeped, and offered him a beer at the ready, suitably chilled. He was happy indeed that he could pick this one up at a bargain price at BestBot, the ‘Lucilius LX refrigerator’, which acted of course as if it had a mind of its own.
from Ivan Tichy’s ‘Mechanica’
https://www.scribd.com/document/318278089/Mechanica-Fables-for-the-Information-Age